The Trials and Traits of Piety, 15.-The Growth of Spiritual Life (F. W. Robertson, M.A.), 20.-Generations United by Common Labour, 41.--Four Attributes of Divine Love (Urijah R. Thomas), 48.-The Body becoming a Second Personality, 49.-The Gospel Mission, 50.-The Grandest of all Heroes, 127.—A Justifiable Hope, 128.—The Glowing Testimony of the Good, 129.-A Model Prayer, 130.-The Morally Sound and Unsound in the Uni- verse, 208.—The Highest Life, 209.-The Abiding Earth (U. R. Thomas), 210. The Divine Method of Estimating Human Conduct, 278.-The Entire Destruction of Moral Evil, 280.-The True Teacher (U. R. Thomas), 281.— God in Relation to Human Work, 282.-Man's Abiding Friend, 351.-The True Life of Man, 352.-Soul Resurrection, 353.-Elijah on Mount Carmel, (F. W. Robertson, M. A.), 355.-Moral Corruption, 405.-The Sweet Light of Life, 407.-Human Life in Retrospect, 408.-Man Blessing the Lord Life in Comparison with Eternity (Edmeston), 47.-Remarks of Various Critics on the New Revision, 51.-Masters and Servants (Shakspeare), 123. -The late Edmond Beales, Esq. M. A., 131.-In Memoriam-Dr. Cum- ming, 135.—The Numbers of the Dead, 138.-Union with Christ (Upham) 169.-Immortality of Goodness (Chalmers), 189.-The Sermon on the Mount (Canon Liddon), 230.-Ranting (C. Kingsley), 243.-The Cross of Christ (J. W. Hancock, L.L.B.), 282.-Creeds (Dr. Dudley), 296.-Philosophy of Rain (Dr.Ure), 335.-Strength, 344.-Prayer (Fenelon), 368.-The Preach- ing to make Great Men, 392.-The Gospel (Goethe), 399.-The Spirit The Double Collapse of Charles Bradlaugh, 68.-The Crossing Sweepers, The Human Race, 69.-Lays of Romance and Chivalry, Bible Tragedies, 70.— Kant and his English Critics, 71.-The Doctrines of Annihilation and Universalism, 72.-Lectures on Teaching, 139.-The Spirit of the Christian Life, 140.-The Jesus of the Evangelists, 141.-The Positive Aspects of Unitarian Thought, George Hope of Fenton Barnes, 142.-Poems of George Heath, Matthew Mellowdew, John's Apocalypse, 143.-The Life- Work in Ireland of a Landlord, Govett's Exposition of St. John, Vol. I., 144.-The New Name, Charles Kingsley's Life, 211.-Stories of the City of London, 212.-The Gospel according to Satan, Index Rerum, The Ladies' Multum in Parvo Flower Garden, 213.-German Prepositions, Phraseology, Geography, Godet's Commentary on Romans, Vol. II. 214.- Life and Times of Dr. Doyle, 215.-Voices of the Dead, Early Education, 216. -Natural Elements of Revealed Theology, 284.-St. Cuthbert of Lindis- farne, The Creed of the Apostle St. John, Life More Abundant, 285.- In Memoriam-Thomas Carlyle, The Book of Judges, The Day after Death, 286.-Geography of the Oceans, 288.-The History and Destiny of Nations, 356.-The Church's Need, 359--Sir Robert Peel, 359.-A Conti- nental Scamper, The Black Speck, Post Mortem, 360.-Girl's Own Annual, Boy's Own Annual, 421.-Clergy List, Pascal's Letters, 422.-Strait Gate, Melancholy, 423.-Moods, The Last Supper, The Teaching of the Bible, 424. NOTE TO FOREIGN SUBSCRIBERS:-Subscribers in the United States, who All COMMUNICATIONS to be addressed to A. THOMAS, 104, Upper Tulse Hill. Leading Homily. 46 THE CARNALITY OF CHURCHISMS. “FOR WHILE ONE SAITH, I AM OF PAUL, AND ANOTHER I AM OF APOLLOS, ARE YE NOT CARNAL?" 1 Cor. iii. 4. N the Church at Corinth there was a variety of elements of thought and feeling. The Roman element was there, and this element was democratic. Indeed the city as it stood in the days of Paul had been built by Julius Cæsar some fifty years before this letter was written, and was undoubtedly populated, to a considerable extent, by freedmen. The tendency in this class of mind would be independency in thought and action. The Greek element was there, the Greek mind was cultured, philosophic, and aesthetic; in teaching, it would crave for the speculative in thought, and the rhetorical in expression. The Jewish element was there, and the craving of the Jewish mind in religion was for marvels, signs, and wonders. In consequence of this variety of mind in the Corinthian Church, there would naturally be much diversity of thought, and VOL. XLIX No. 1. B discussions which would lead to divisions. "The Jews require a sign, and the Greeks seek after wisdom, but we preach Christ crucified, unto the Jews a stumbling block, and unto the Greeks foolishness." The Jews lived in signs and the Greeks deified wisdom. The members of the Corinthian Church, therefore, at this time instead of being thoroughly united in soul one with another, by having Christ as the supreme subject of thought, and supreme object of love, were divided by certain forms of religious thought and types of religious teaching. No two men, however enlightened and honest, will have exactly the same views on the same subject, or present those views in identical aspects. Paul would not give out exactly the same views in exactly the same way as Apollos did, or as Peter did, or either of them as the other, and their auditors would therefore have their preferences. Herein we have the philosophy of the existence of various Churches and sects. The text suggests to us the nature and the carnality of Churchism. I. The NATURE of Churchism. What is it? Those in the Corinthian Church who said, "I am of Paul," "I am of Apollos," and "I am of Peter," had such an exaggerated estimate of, and excessive and vaunting devotion to, the opinions and preaching of their particular favourites, as led them to ignore and even depreciate the merits of the others. To the Paulites there was no teacher equal to him, no Gospel equal to his-so with the Peterites, and so with the admirers of Apollos. The worth of one man's opinions and ministry was magnified to the ignorement and disvaluing of those of others. This I call Churchism. To become members of institutions called Churches, to adopt and advocate the peculiar views they represent, may be right enough, and peradventure useful. To meet together in a community of those with whose ideas, sympathies, and aims, we have the most in common, is both proper and salutary. It affords opportunities for mutual counselling and spiritual stimulation, to elevating thoughts and sacred devotions. But when that communion becomes the centre and circumference of our souls it is Churchism or sectarianism. What are Churches? The best Churches that exist in Christendom to-day are but the organisation of certain human opinions concerning Christ and His Gospel. Man's theories of the Gospel are no more the Gospel than physiological theories are life. Calvin had his views―he propounded them, many endorsed and adopted them. Luther had his views-he set them forth before the eyes of men and enforced them, they were accepted by multitudes and organised into Churches. Wesley had his views—which he advocated with saintly zeal, numbers adopted them, and they were organised into Churches. Edward Irving had his apocalypses, and his dreams were organised into Churches. And thus we have Roman Catholic Churches, Greek Churches, Episcopal Churches, Presbyterian Churches, Wesleyan Churches, Morisonian Churches, Unitarian Churches, Congregational Churches, and Baptist Churches. What are they all? Nothing more, I trow, than various human opinions of the Gospel embodied in institutions. And though the human opinions and theories thus organised are varied, contradictory, and never absolutely true, they nevertheless attract to them men of various types of religious thought and forms of religious feeling, so that on all hands we hear each devotee of his Church extolling its pre-eminent merits. |